By ankit chauhan, October 31, 2007 - 16:08 IST 0 of 1 people found this review helpful
so....here we have mr. kashyap directing the first movie from the so called "psy" genre...the effort is more than appreciable ....i cant still figure out why so many people have treated the movie so harshly while reviewing this movie...or may be they could nt digest the successful implementation of the concept...AND WHO SAYS THE MOVIE DOES NT TALK ABT QUITTING SMOKING...EACH AND EVERY FRAME TRIES TO CONVEY THAT SO SIMPLY!!...JOHN DOES A MIND BLOWING JOB...BUT I HAVE SOME RESERVATIONS abt the screenplay...it seems patchy in various parts of the movie...and if mr. kashyap had spent a little more time on the final sequence,it would have made the film more impactful...but KUDOS to
MR. KASHYAP TO SHOW HIS COURAGE AND MAKE THIS MOVIE... AND OF COURSE BRINGING THE HELL OUT OF KHALID MOHAMMAD...
What I liked about the movie:
marvelous editing and fine acting by john..mesmerising cinematography..
What I didn't like about the movie:
girl singing in adnan sami s voice in the song jab bhi cigarette...
unwanted sequences in between important sequences...
Would you recommend this movie to your friend: Yes
